Cathy's Ice Cream & Candy Shoppe

Amazing ice cream sandwiches. Finally a place with treats that taste as good as they look. Super friendly service makes it a must try. I had the chocolate chip cookies with cookies and cream ice cream rolled in Oreos with caramel. It was perfect

I’ve always loved ice cream sandwiches and this place puts it over the top. Located in the Arcade downtown, it was a little tough to get to with a car, but we managed to eventually find street parking. The wife and kid got the cookie sandwich while I got the Churro Ice Cream sandwich. The churro was made right in front of me, however it came out extremely crispy and hard, mostly like a churro cookie. Had it been a bit softer, it would’ve been outstanding. The banana pudding ice cream I put in it was a great suggestion to compliment the cinnamon and sugar churro.

Cookie was great..Luv the concept.. They added sales on food which shouldn’t be!!

Literally amazing. I got a chocolate chip cookie sandwich with salted caramel peanut ice cream and chocolate chips. It was so good. The cookies were warm, the ice cream was tasty and soft. Great customer service! Unfortunately you can’t leave a tip with your card while checking out. They need to fix their system to allow that.

The treats live up to the hype! The cookies are baked PERFECTLY, and the ice cream is applied GENEROUSLY! The only downside to the ice cream sandwiches is that they're too large to easily eat. (HINT: do not attempt while walking downtown!) Overall, the experience was wonderful, and I'll definitely be returning again!

Loved it! Poor girl was working all by herself and several people in line but she managed to get the cookies in and out of the oven and help everyone in a reasonable time. The cookies were chewy but had that crunch, I had the snickerdoodles with carrot cake ice cream. Even if you just get the cookie or the ice cream they were both excellent! Will be back!

Was walking by and saw the advertisement in the window, which caught my attention. Ordered 2 ice cream sandwiches, which was feeding 2 adults. We were told the cookies were going to be soft and warm. There was a selection of about 8 or so cookies, but they definitely weren't soft nor warm. The portions are big, so unless you're making it a meal, keep to sharing. We couldn't finish 2 of them. They were very messy, but can't say they were not good. Just not what we thought they were going to be like provided we were told something differently prior to ordering.

Good ice cream and a good concept, though they did not live up to expectations. It's probably somewhat due to the fact that I've been to the West Coast based Baked Bear, but they did not excel. Don't get me wrong, they we're definitely good and worth going to. Not a turn off flavors but they definitely taste great.

Who doesn't like warm cookies and a healthy serving of ice cream? I'm working home during shelter in place, but Cathy's is definitely worth a field trip downtown.